Research in Action: Dr. Erin Hobin
Research in Action
12 Jan 2017
Preventing chronic disease: making the healthier choice the easier choice
If you’ve wondered how many calories are in your favourite submarine sandwich or tried to figure out the nutritional content of a kids’ meal at a fast food restaurant, so has Dr. Erin Hobin. Her research on nutrition labelling in supermarkets and menu items in restaurants is turning up answers that have big implications for our health.
A scientist at Public Heath Ontario, Hobin looks at policies or programs that promote healthy eating and physical activity in the population as a whole. Some of her most intriguing findings relate to food offerings at fast food restaurants and how much information is available to consumers.
“People are eating a lot of empty calories and high sodium foods, often unknowingly,” said Hobin. “Supporting people in making more informed choices is essential to changing our food environment.”
Hobin saw a pressing need to better understand the nutritional content in fast food items and menu labelling, both under-researched topics in Canada.
Fig. 1 Forest plot comparing relative estimates of mean calories of fast food Kids’ Menu foods across countries.
Fig. 2 Forest plot comparing relative estimates of mean sodium content of fast food Kids’ Menu foods across countries.
In October 2013, Hobin made headlines with a study she led on kids’ menus in fast food restaurants in five countries. The researchers compared the calories, sodium, total fat and saturated fat of food items offered on kids’ menus in the largest multinational fast food chains in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States. The team also examined potential effects of new legislation in the U.S. requiring calorie labelling on restaurant menus, and recommendations for voluntary sodium reduction targets in the U.K.
Notably, the study showed that kids’ menu food items contained significantly fewer calories in fast food restaurants in the U.S., where menu labelling is required.
On average, a single food item on kids’ menus in those restaurants contained 63 fewer calories compared to those in other countries. In the U.K., the average sodium content of a kids’ menu item contained 150mg less sodium compared to menu items in other countries. Food items on kids’ menus in fast food restaurants in Canada contained, on average, the highest sodium content and the second highest amount of calories compared to the other countries studied.
“Children are important targets for nutrition interventions,” says Hobin. “Nearly one-third of children are overweight or obese, and kids’ meals are the top selling fast food items sold to children under the age of 13.”
Hobin says her findings may indicate that restaurants in some countries are responding to government initiatives to improve food environments. What’s more, these initiatives can lead to an improvement in the nutritional quality of food items directly targeting kids.
But what kind of nutrition information is actually available, and in what format, in our restaurants? Hobin is set to publish findings from a study, funded by the Propel Centre for Population Health Impact at the University of Waterloo, of the top ten fast food restaurants in Canada.
It’s a timely topic as jurisdictions across Canada consider how to get better nutrition information to consumers. The Government of Ontario, for example, has announced plans to introduce mandatory menu labelling legislation in restaurants with five or more locations across the province.
What we buy in grocery stores is also on Hobin’s radar. For example, she’s investigating how implementing a simple on-shelf nutrition rating system located beside an item’s price may affect Canadians food purchasing decisions. Funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), her multi-year study investigates changes in consumer food purchasing patterns in supermarkets across Canada with and without this on-shelf nutrition rating system.
In addition to studying the impact of an on-shelf nutrition rating system, Hobin has also received funding from the Canadian Foundation for Dietetic Research to investigate how changes to the Nutrition Facts tables on pre-packaged foods can support young people in Canada to make more informed food choices. More specifically, this study looks at whether standardizing serving sizes and interpreting % Daily Value information using simple high/medium and low descriptors on the Nutrition Facts tables of similar products can make easier the comparison of foods’ nutritional quality. This study will help to inform potential changes to regulations related to Nutrition Facts tables in Canada.
Hobin is also excited about a CIHR-funded study she just finished. It examined the impact of a Manitoba-wide policy that mandates physical education every year for students in grades nine to twelve. Policy-makers will use the results to improve implementation of the policy.
For Hobin, ‘population-level interventions’ (programs or policies that affect large groups of people) are essential to changing behaviour.
“When behaviours or conditions are affecting a large proportion of the population, it’s too hard to just address change on an individual level. It’s a lot easier to be inactive and eat poorly than to make healthier choices,” she says. “We need to create an environment where people are directed to the right choices. The purpose of policy or environmental changes is to try to make the healthier choice the easier choice.”
By collaborating with government, industry and others, Hobin says her work is providing “relevant and applicable” evidence to inform population-level programs and policies — and advance the fight against chronic disease.
- Hobin E, So J, Rosella L, Comte M, Manske S, McGavock J. Trajectories of Objectively Measured Physical Activity Among Secondary Students in Canada in the Context of a Province-Wide Physical Education Policy: A Longitudinal Analysis. Journal of Obesity Volume 2014 (2014), Article ID 95864.
- Hobin E, Hammond D, White C, Lennon L, Chiu M, O’Brien, M. Nutritional quality of food items on fast food “Kids’ Menus”: comparisons across countries and companies. Public Health Nutr; Forthcoming 2013.
- Hobin EP, Hammond DG, Daniel S, Hanning RM, Manske S. The Happy Meal® effect: The impact of toy premiums on healthy eating among children in Ontario, Canadahttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23618634?dopt=abstract. Can J Public Health. 2012;103(4):e244-8.
- Hobin EP, Leatherdale ST, Manske S, Dubin JA, Elliott S, Veugelers P. A multilevel examination of gender differences in the association between features of the school environment and physical activity among a sample of grades 9 to 12 students in Ontario, Canada. BMC Public Health. 2012;12:74,2458-12-74.
- Hobin E, Hayward S, Riley B, DiRuggerio E, Birdsell J. The intersection between population health intervention research and knowledge translation: implications for policy, practice, and research. Evidence and Policy, 2012;8(1):97-115.
PHO Grand Rounds: “Communities are attempting to tackle this crisis”: a scoping review of community overdose responses
Using integrated knowledge translation, we involved experts and knowledge users in conducting, interpreting, reporting and discussing the application of these findings.
This presentation summarizes our preliminary results and considers how this knowledge could be used to inform practice across Canada.